Meiorin CaseNEW TEST FOR REASONABLE ACCOMMODATIONBritish Columbia (Public Service Employee Relations Comm.) v. B.C.G.E.U. (1999), 35 C.H.R.R. D/257 (S.C.C.)The Supreme Court of Canada holds that the Government of British Columbia’s aerobic standard used to test the fitness of forest firefighters discriminates on the basis of sex, and further that the Government failed to show that the discriminatory standard is justified as a bona fide occupational requirement (“BFOR”).This case arose as a grievance before a labour arbitrator. Tawney Meiorin was employed for three years as a member of the Initial Attack Forest Firefighting crew. Although she did her work well, she lost her job when the Government adopted a new series of fitness tests for forest firefighters. She passed three of the tests but failed a fourth one, a 2.5 km run designed to assess whether she met the Government’s aerobic standards, by taking 49.4 seconds longer than required.The arbitrator found that the aerobic standard constituted adverse effect discrimination based on sex because men as a group have a higher aerobic capacity than women, and consequently are more able to meet the standard. The average man, with training, could meet the standard. The average woman, with training, could not meet the standard. Consequently, the same standard applied to both sexes excluded more women than men.The arbitrator also concluded that the Government did not show that it had accommodated Ms. Meiorin to the point of undue hardship. The arbitrator ordered that Ms. Meiorin be reinstated and compensated for lost wages and benefits. This arbitral ruling was overturned by the British Columbia Court of AppealIn the view of the Supreme Court of Canada the narrow issue is whether the Government improperly dismissed Ms. Meiorin from her job as a forest firefighter. The broader issue is whether the aerobic standard unfairly excludes women from forest firefighting jobs.The aerobic standard was developed for the Government by University of Victoria researchers. The Court finds that two aspects of the researchers’ methodology are problematic in this case. First, it was primarily descriptive, based on measuring average performance levels, and converting this data into minimum performance standards. Therefore, it did not demonstrate that these performance standards were in fact necessary to the safe and efficient performance of the job. Second, it did not seem to distinguish between male and female test subjects. The record did not show whether women and men require the same minimum level of aerobic capacity to perform this job safely and efficiently.The Court holds that the Court of Appeal mistakenly read the arbitrator’s reasons as finding that the aerobic standard was necessary to the safe and efficient performance of work. The arbitrator found, on the contrary, that despite her failure to meet the standard Ms. Meiorin did not pose a serious safety risk to herself, her colleagues, or the general public. The arbitrator did not find that meeting the aerobic standard was necessary to safe and efficient job performance.The Court agrees with the arbitrator that on the conventional legal approach to applying human rights legislation a case of adverse effect discrimination was made out and the Government failed to show that it had accommodated to the point of undue hardship.However, the Court decides that the conventional analysis should be revisited. The conventional analysis has distinguished between direct discrimination and adverse effect discrimination, defining direct discrimination as that which is open or overt, discriminatory on its face, and adverse effect discrimination as that which results from the discriminatory effects of seemingly neutral practices. The defence to direct discrimination has been to show that the rule is a bona fide occupational requirement. Absent such a showing, the rule would be struck down. The defence to adverse effect discrimination has been to show that a complainant could not be accommodated without undue hardship. This bifurcated approach has caused some confusion on the part of tribunals and courts, and the Supreme Court of Canada takes this occasion to articulate a new “unified” approach which avoids the distinction between direct and adverse effect discrimination.Under the unified approach there is a three-step test for determining whether a discriminatory standard is a BFOR. The employer must establish:1. the standard was adopted for a purpose that is rationally connected to job performance;2. the particular standard was adopted in an honest and good faith belief that it was necessary to the fulfillment of that legitimate work-related purpose;3. the standard is reasonably necessary to the accomplishment of that legitimate purpose. This includes a requirement to demonstrate that it is impossible to accommodate without undue hardship.Applying the unified approach to this case, the Court holds that Ms. Meiorin discharged the burden of establishing that, prima facie, the standard discriminates against women, and the Government has not shown that the standard is reasonably necessary. The Government did not show that it would experience undue hardship if a different standard were used.The Court disagrees with the Court of Appeal that accommodating women by permitting them to meet a different aerobic standard necessarily discriminates against men. The Court also finds that individual testing, without more, does not negate discrimination.The appeal is allowed, and the order of the arbitrator is restored, with costs to the appellant in this Court and the Court below.
Why Choose Us
Do you need to ace that test? We are here to help you. We have qualified writers to present you with a 100% error-free paper. Toptutor4me offers you a unique and personalized custom paper that will assist you in getting that good grade.
Your paper will go through high editorial standards to meet your satisfaction. We have qualified writers to assist you to reach your academic goal without going through academic stress. We put into consideration the paper formatting, the pages required, valid citations, and included files to present you with an acceptable paper.
Our writers have a comprehensive experience and have perfected the art of crafting your paper. Regardless of the academic level or topic, we are prepared to provide a quality custom paper upon your order request.
Each paper is written with our customers' preferences into consideration and strict plagiarism-free rules are adhered to. Order now and experience our excellent paper services.
Professional Academic Writers
A student needs professional assistance outside class time. Our writers possess Ph.D. in different fields and hold several years’ experience. Before hiring our writers, we give them tests and strictly consider their educational backgrounds.
After the sieving process, they are trained to ensure they deliver well-structured papers to our customers. Our experts work around the clock to provide correct answers and give any educational help. They not only deliver on time but also follow the customers’ instructions.
Every writer is a fluent native speaker of English and is from the USA, Canada, UK, or Australia. Our experts approach tasks effectively depending on their specialization. Here are some qualities our writers' possess;
Is the deal too good to be true? Toptutor4me is a reliable assignment help website on the market that considers students’ daily needs for academic help. Our assignment help is reasonably priced to approximately 90% of students around the world.
Our objective is to help students achieve academic excellence and we believe that inconsiderable charges should not hinder a student from getting the desired help.
In case the customer is not satisfied, we offer revisions and rewrites without extra charges. There are no unpleasant surprise charges at the checkout. We ensure maximum privacy and safe payment services. Our services are not only cheap but also have several advantages such as;
Tight deadline? Paper due tomorrow? Do not worry our writers are ready to help. Students have difficulties balancing their social and academic life, therefore, getting caught up with academic deadlines.
Your order is given the immediate attention it requires regardless of its complexity.
Tackling your assignment at the last minute does not give you the advantage of carrying out extensive research and coming up with correct answers. Our experienced writers are knowledgeable and always available to work on your paper.
Deadline is a trouble every student faces and our urgent writing services are the ultimate solutions. We have a 24/7 support team that is eager to tend to your concerns and give you the ultimate customer experience.
We guarantee you that outstanding papers are delivered on time at the customer's convenience. All you have to do is place an order giving a specific time delivery that works in your favor.
The ultimate deal-breaker in achieving a good grade is submitting an imitative paper. Plagiarism is a breach of examination standards and has serious consequences. Lecturers test the students' understanding of the taught topic by checking for originality.
Despite carrying out online and book research the student needs to deliver answers in their understanding by paraphrasing the research findings and providing relevant citations. Our experts' main consideration is providing a free plagiarized paper that will meet the teachers' requirements.
They have perfected the skill of presenting unique personalized papers with relevant citations and references if needed. We ensure extreme originality and in case of any customer concerns, we offer a plagiarism report.
Our editorial department proofreads the papers before they are sent to the customer therefore you should be assured that substandard work will not be delivered. We want to work under customer's trust that their paper is unique and will support them in accomplishing the best grade.
Customer Support 24/7
Our website is user-friendly and super useful! Mycoursewriter is an online writing service that is always available to provide you with academic assistance you need.
Customers’ concerns are considered by our friendly customer support team that is available at all times. Toptutor4me has a support team that answers your questions immediately.
If you have trouble placing an order you can reach our team through the tawk.to live chat that will give you step-to-step guidance. We value our customers' satisfaction and put into consideration any raised concerns.
Over ten years’ experience in the writing market has enabled us to grow and learn how to give our customers the golden experience. The website usability is self-learnable but in case of any problem feel free to contact us.
We have diligently satisfied hundreds of students and you can witness this at the toptutor4me review page. Do not hesitate to contact us at our website email: email@example.com
Try it now!
How it works?
Follow these simple steps to get your paper done
Place your order
Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.
Proceed with the payment
Choose the payment system that suits you most.
Receive the final file
Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.
Are you searching for a satisfactory legitimate writing website? Look no further. Toptutor4me is the best writing service ready to offer you long-term support in your academic needs. We have been providing homework help for years that has gained our customers’ trust. Our writers are ready to work on any assignment type from undergrad to Ph.D. level.
We guarantee you quality papers, timely delivery, and 24/7 response. Our website is not only the cheapest but also authentic and the most unfailing with an assurance team that manages our orders. We offer assignment help in every subject and topic despite the difficulty, let us ease your assignment burden. Below are examples of the papers we offer;
Essay writing is a commonly assigned college homework. Sitting down for an hour or so crafting a perfect essay is a tedious time-consuming task. You might find yourself staring at a blank paper surfing through different websites trying to devise answers for your essay.
Toptutor4me is a legit service that offers to write your essay at a pocket-friendly price. Your essay is given maximum attention by the assigned professional writer who includes fresh ideas and personalizes your paper to your preference. Order essay help by including the question, the page number, preferred format, and any files related to your essay.
Our essays are unique and go through a strict protocol that includes anti-plagiarism and rigorous proofreading. You do not have to struggle with finding ideas for your essay as our writers are not only skilled but also have the correct answers for your paper. Let our scholars work on your essay and you can take care of other responsibilities besides your student tasks.
Admission and Business Papers
Writing an admission paper is not everyone’s inclination but this should not be a hindrance to fulfilling your goal. Writing a perfect paper to get you to that school or company imposes mind stress as there are certain expectations you must meet.
Failure to meet these expectations might make your dream unfulfilled. Admission papers require you to be unique, open, and display confidence but not seem aggressive. A business paper necessitates the student to be aware of current happenings in the world and have a wide knowledge of the business history and trends.
These needs research and skills and we have the qualified writers to meet all these prospects that will satisfy your assessor or lecturer. Our team will help you conquer that milestone in your academic life or your career all you need to do is provide the necessary information for our writers to craft your paper.
Editing and Proofreading
An error-free paper is a must in achieving that desired grade. We have an assurance team to ensure your paper has no grammar or formatting mistakes.
After our writers have given correct answers to your question in the necessary pages, our editorial team proofreads the paper to ensure quality work. They check for grammar mistakes, plagiarism and ensure proper paper formatting.
Issues such as the specified fonts, spacing, and educational formats are considered. We can also provide the plagiarism reports if needed. Our team has skills in formatting any paper type be it MLA, APA, Harvard, or Chicago. Under no circumstances will a poorly formatted paper be forwarded to you as we ensure careful proofreading.
Assignments are part of the learning process and one may not have the knowledge of the correct answers, this should not stress you as we have qualified scholars to help you.
A challenging topic does not imply that you should fail. Our qualified writers hold PhDs in different subjects therefore they are intelligent and no task is complex to them. Despite the complexity, a competent scholar will be assigned to meet your academic needs.
Different assignments are confusing as they may involve different skills that you are not familiar with. This is not an issue to our skilled professional writers as they provide the correct answers for any essay type despite the intricacy. Stop stressing about your homework by ordering assignment help at Mycoursewriter and go have fun!