Supreme Court of Lincoln Land

Supreme Court of Lincoln Land Jill Ingram, Plaintiff v. Ralph Sullivan, Defendant   Allen, Chief Justice, delivered the opinion of the court. Plaintiff, Jill Ingram, owns and operates a “bed-and-breakfast.” On February 1, 2015, she entered into an agreement with the defendant, Ralph Sullivan, doing business under the name “Ralphie’s Window Washing Service.” The terms of the agreement provided that the defendant agreed to wash the windows of the plaintiff’s building on a weekly basis during the period April 1 to December 31, 2015, for a total price of $10,000, payable in weekly installments. At the time the agreement was entered into by the parties, the defendant was 17 years old and just two weeks shy of his 18th birthday. Plaintiff did not know or even think about the defendant’s age. He was of mature appearance, operated his own business, and approached plaintiff to solicit the work. Although plaintiff was unaware of the defendant’s domestic circumstances, he had in fact been living on his own for some time and was financially independent of his parents. Two days after entering into the agreement with plaintiff, defendant accepted a more lucrative business opportunity that precluded him from performing the window washing services for plaintiff. He therefore called plaintiff and told her that he was no longer able to wash her windows. At this stage the contract was fully executory – that is, no services had been performed under the contract, and no payments had been made. After trying in vain to persuade defendant to honor his undertaking, plaintiff made inquiries and found another person to perform the same services for a fee of $15,000. This was the cheapest substitute available. Plaintiff then sued defendant for $5,000, the difference between what the services would have cost her under the contract with defendant and what they cost under the substitute transaction. This is the correct measure of damages because it compensates plaintiff for her disappointed expectation and places her in the same position she would have been in had the contract been performed. However, these damages are only recoverable if defendant’s refusal to perform was an actionable breach of contract. None of the above facts were disputed at trial. Defendant admitted entering into and subsequently refusing to perform the contract. The sole defense that he raised was that he was a minor at the time of contracting and therefore had the right to avoid the contract, which he did a couple of days later. The trial court found in favor of the defendant on this issue of law and granted judgment in his favor. On appeal to this court, plaintiff concedes that defendant was a minor both when entering into and terminating the contract. However, plaintiff urges us to hold defendant bound to the contract under the circumstances of this case: Defendant was almost 18, operated his own business, looked mature, lived independently of his parents and fully understood the nature of the transaction. Plaintiff dealt fairly with defendant and had no knowledge of his age. In effect, while plaintiff acknowledges that a minor’s contract is normally avoidable, she contends that the application of that rule in the present case would be highly technical and unfair. While this argument has some appeal, it is contrary to the law and policy of this state and must fail. At common law, a person attained the age of majority at 21. However, in 1960 the legislature of this state changed the age of majority to 18. The statute expressly states that “until midnight on the day preceding a person’s 18th birthday, that person shall be a minor for all purpose in law.” Clearly, then, defendant was a minor both when he contracted and disaffirmed his contract. The law of this state on minors’ contracts was first pronounced on by this court in Williams v. Underhill, 50 LL Reports 100 (1958), in which we held that a contract entered into by a minor may be avoided by the minor, either expressly or by implication, at any time before attaining majority age or within a reasonable time thereafter. As we explained in the Williams opinion, this rule is intended to protect minors from improvidence and bad judgment and to prevent advantage-taking by adults. The rationale is as applicable today as it was when first advanced, and the rule has been followed ever since. Plaintiff refers us to Tannenbaum v. Gump, 52 LL Reports 142 (1959), in which we recognized an exception to the rule where a minor had become fully emancipated from her parents as a result of marrying and setting up her own home. However, the marital status of the minor was a material element of that case and distinguishes it from the situation before use today. Given the law’s purpose of affording protection to minors, we are not inclined to broaden the rule in Tannenbaum. It may be true, as plaintiff argues, that is technical and unfair to allow an independent and mature minor to avoid a contract entered into so close to majority. However, this argument invites the court to abandon a clear and definitive rule in favor of a case-by-case investigation into the minor’s circumstances. While it may be arbitrary to fix contractual capacity as arising at a precise hour on a person’s 18th birthday, this rule is at least predictable and easy to apply. A fact-based analysis of a minor’s actual ability to use mature judgment would create uncertainty in the law and would surely encourage litigation. The arbitrary rule does not really impose great hardship on the major party who has the opportunity to demand proof of age whenever dealing with a person of youthful appearance. In any event, even if plaintiff’s argument has merit, it is better addressed to the legislature than to the courts, because the legislature has spoken on this matter and we have no authority to disregard a clear statutory provision. Finally, we note in passing that plaintiff has referred us to several decisions from other states in which it has been held that a minor loses the right to disaffirm a contract where he or she has misrepresented his or her age. The wisdom of such decisions may be called into question, given the policy of protecting minors from improvident and irresponsible behavior. Nonetheless, we need not pass on this question here, because there is no evidence that defendant affirmatively misrepresented his age. It is not enough to constitute a misrepresentation that a minor simply appears to be over 18 and says nothing to counter that impression. We therefore find that the trial court did not err in giving judgment to the defendant and we affirm.   Tice, Justice, concurring.   I agree with the conclusion reached by the court on the facts of this case. However, I write separately to emphasize that I take the majority’s opinion to be confined to a wholly executory contract. Had the contract been performed in whole or in part, it would have been appropriate for the court to take this into account in deciding whether to enforce this contract. In this respect, I take a more expansive view of the court’s discretion in these matters than the majority seems to assert.   Wiggins, Justice, dissenting.   In allowing defendant to avoid this contract, the majority adopts an absurdly rigid approach. While it is true that minors need protection from improvident action and exploitation by adults, there is no evidence in this case to suggest that any such factors were present. Rather, defendant unscrupulously reneged on his contractual promise for the sake of exploiting more profitable economic opportunities. Given the age and independence of the defendant, he was in fact emancipated. His situation is really indistinguishable from that of the married minor in Tannenbaum, and the rule in that case should have been followed here. By refusing to extend that rule, and narrowly confining the Tannenbaum decision to fact of marriage, the majority allows the defendant to escape his undertaking with impunity and teaches young people a very poor lesson on business ethics. The advantage of legal certainty is greatly outweighed by the need to do justice between the parties in specific cases. Furthermore, the majority’s claim that its hands are tied by statute is misconceived. The statute simply fixes the age of majority. It says nothing of the court’s power at common law to recognize appropriate exceptions to the general rule concerning the avoidability of minors’ contracts. Indeed, the rule in Tannenbaum was already in existence at the time that the statute was enacted, and no one has suggested that the statute was intended to overrule it. For the above reason, I dissent from the majority opinion and would reverse the decision of the lower court.     Answer the following questions based on this opinion.   1) The ruling or holding of the case, simply stated, is that the defendant has a legal right to rescind (i.e. cancel) the contract. What material facts did the court rely on as the basis for its holding?   2) Is the dissenting opinion precedent?   3) Identify the rationale(s) used to support the majority opinion.   4) Why did Justice Tice write a concurring opinion?   5) Consider the treatment of the Tannenbaum decision in the majority and dissenting opinions. What does this tell you about the process of following precedent?   6) Assume that after this opinion was issued in Ingram v. Sullivan, a trial court in Lincoln Land has to resolve a case in which a minor deliberately and expressly misrepresented to the adult party that she was 20 years old and bolstered this misrepresentation by producing a fake driver’s license. Is our case, Ingram v. Sullivan, controlling precedent in this case? If not, does our case offer any guidance to the trial court in deciding how to resolve the latter case?   7) Assume that after Ingram v. Sullivan, the supreme court of a different state has to resolve a case with substantially the same facts. Is the Ingram case binding precedent in this other jurisdiction?   8) In another subsequent case before a trial court in Lincoln Land, the facts are almost identical to Ingram v. Sullivan. The only difference is that the minor terminated the contract one week after his 18th birthday and before the services had been delivered and paid for. How does Ingram affect the disposition of this case? Is it still binding precedent?

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Custom Essay on
Supreme Court of Lincoln Land
From $8/Page
Order Essay
Toptutor4me
Order NOW For A 10% Discount!
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Why Choose Us

Quality Papers

Do you need to ace that test? We are here to help you. We have qualified writers to present you with a 100% error-free paper. Toptotur4me offers you a unique and personalized custom paper that will assist you in getting that good grade. Your paper will go through high editorial standards to meet your satisfaction. We have qualified writers to assist you to reach your academic goal without going through academic stress. We put into consideration the paper formatting, the pages required, valid citations, and included files to present you with an acceptable paper. Our writers have a comprehensive experience and have perfected the art of crafting your paper. Regardless of the academic level or topic, we are prepared to provide a quality custom paper upon your order request. Each paper is written with our customers' preferences into consideration and strict plagiarism-free rules are adhered to. Order now and experience our excellent paper services.

Professional Academic Writers

A student needs professional assistance outside class time. Our writers possess Ph.D. in different fields and hold several years’ experience. Before hiring our writers, we give them tests and strictly consider their educational backgrounds. After the sieving process, they are trained to ensure they deliver well-structured papers to our customers. Our experts work around the clock to provide correct answers and give any educational help. They not only deliver on time but also follow the customers’ instructions. Every writer is a fluent native speaker of English and is from the USA, Canada, UK, or Australia. Our experts approach tasks effectively depending on their specialization. Here are some qualities our writers' possess;• Punctuality • Good communication skills • Fluent in English • Vast knowledge in different subjects • Ability to work under pressure

Affordable Prices

Is the deal too good to be true? Toptutor4me is a reliable assignment help website on the market that considers students’ daily needs for academic help. Our assignment help is reasonably priced to approximately 90% of students around the world. Our objective is to help students achieve academic excellence and we believe that inconsiderable charges should not hinder a student from getting the desired help. Our goal is not financial gain but rather helping students achieve their academic goals. In case the customer is not satisfied, we offer revisions and rewrites without extra charges. There are no unpleasant surprise charges at the checkout. We ensure maximum privacy and safe payment services. Our services are not only cheap but also have several advantages such as; • 24/7 services • Customer-friendly team • Timely delivery • Refund policy • Quality papers • Professional academic help Thanks to our website you can get your paper completed exceptionally at a cheaper price.

On-Time delivery

Tight deadline? Paper due tomorrow? Do not worry our writers are ready to help. Students have difficulties balancing their social and academic life, therefore, getting caught up with academic deadlines. Tackling your assignment at the last minute does not give you the advantage of carrying out extensive research and coming up with correct answers. Our experienced writers are knowledgeable and always available to work on your paper. Your order is given the immediate attention it requires regardless of its complexity. Deadline is a trouble every student faces and our urgent writing services are the ultimate solutions. We have a 24/7 support team that is eager to tend to your concerns and give you the ultimate customer experience. We guarantee you that outstanding papers are delivered on time at the customer's convenience. All you have to do is place an order giving a specific time delivery that works in your favor.

100% Originality

The ultimate deal-breaker in achieving a good grade is submitting an imitative paper. Plagiarism is a breach of examination standards and has serious consequences. Lecturers test the students' understanding of the taught topic by checking for originality. Despite carrying out online and book research the student needs to deliver answers in their understanding by paraphrasing the research findings and providing relevant citations. Our experts' main consideration is providing a free plagiarized paper that will meet the teachers' requirements. They have perfected the skill of presenting unique personalized papers with relevant citations and references if needed. We ensure extreme originality and in case of any customer concerns, we offer a plagiarism report. Our editorial department proofreads the papers before they are sent to the customer therefore you should be assured that substandard work will not be delivered. We want to work under customer's trust that their paper is unique and will support them in accomplishing the best grade.

Customer Support 24/7

Our website is user-friendly and super useful! Toptutor4me is an online writing service that is always available to provide you with academic assistance you need. Customers’ concerns are considered by our friendly customer support team that is available at all times. Toptutor4me has a support team that answers your questions immediately. If you have trouble placing an order you can reach our team through the tawk.to live chat that will give you step-to-step guidance. We value our customers' satisfaction and put into consideration any raised concerns. Over ten years’ experience in the writing market has enabled us to grow and learn how to give our customers the golden experience. The website usability is self-learnable but in case of any problem feel free to contact us. We have diligently satisfied hundreds of students and you can witness this at the topwriters4me review page. Do not hesitate to contact us at our website email: support@toptutor4me.com

Try it now!

Calculate the price of your order

We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:
$0.00

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Services

Are you searching for a satisfactory legitimate writing website? Look no further. Topwriters4me is the best writing service ready to offer you long-term support in your academic needs. We have been providing homework help for years that has gained our customers’ trust. Our writers are ready to work on any assignment type from undergrad to Ph.D. level. We guarantee you quality papers, timely delivery, and 24/7 response. Our website is not only the cheapest but also authentic and the most unfailing with an assurance team that manages our orders. We offer assignment help in every subject and topic despite the difficulty, let us ease your assignment burden. Below are examples of the papers we offer; • Article writing • Lab report • Annotated bibliography • Research paper • Capstone projects • PowerPoint presentation • Personal statements • Dissertation writing

Essays

Essay Writing Services

Essay writing is a commonly assigned college homework. Sitting down for an hour or so crafting a perfect essay is a tedious time-consuming task. You might find yourself staring at a blank paper surfing through different websites trying to devise answers for your essay. Topwriters4me is a legit service that offers to write your essay at a pocket-friendly price. Your essay is given maximum attention by the assigned professional writer who includes fresh ideas and personalizes your paper to your preference. Order essay help by including the question, the page number, preferred format, and any files related to your essay. Our essays are unique and go through a strict protocol that includes anti-plagiarism and rigorous proofreading. You do not have to struggle with finding ideas for your essay as our writers are not only skilled but also have the correct answers for your paper. Let our scholars work on your essay and you can take care of other responsibilities besides your student tasks.

Admissions

Admission and Business Papers

Writing an admission paper is not everyone’s inclination but this should not be a hindrance to fulfilling your goal. Writing a perfect paper to get you to that school or company imposes mind stress as there are certain expectations you must meet. Failure to meet these expectations might make your dream unfulfilled. Admission papers require you to be unique, open, and display confidence but not seem aggressive. A business paper necessitates the student to be aware of current happenings in the world and have a wide knowledge of the business history and trends. These needs research and skills and we have the qualified writers to meet all these prospects that will satisfy your assessor or lecturer. Our team will help you conquer that milestone in your academic life or your career all you need to do is provide the necessary information for our writers to craft your paper.

Editing

Editing and Proofreading

An error-free paper is a must in achieving that desired grade. We have an assurance team to ensure your paper has no grammar or formatting mistakes. After our writers have given correct answers to your question in the necessary pages, our editorial team proofreads the paper to ensure quality work. They check for grammar mistakes, plagiarism and ensure proper paper formatting. Issues such as the specified fonts, spacing, and educational formats are considered. We can also provide the plagiarism reports if needed. Our team has skills in formatting any paper type be it MLA, APA, Harvard, or Chicago. Under no circumstances will a poorly formatted paper be forwarded to you as we ensure careful proofreading.

Coursework

Technical Papers

Assignments are part of the learning process and one may not have the knowledge of the correct answers, this should not stress you as we have qualified scholars to help you. A challenging topic does not imply that you should fail. Our qualified writers hold PhDs in different subjects therefore they are intelligent and no task is complex to them. Despite the complexity, a competent scholar will be assigned to meet your academic needs. Different assignments are confusing as they may involve different skills that you are not familiar with. This is not an issue to our skilled professional writers as they provide the correct answers for any essay type despite the intricacy. Stop stressing about your homework by ordering assignment help at Toptutor4me and go have fun!